The Facebook Churban
3:08 pm in Arts, Inspiration, Jewish Home, Parenting, Woman of the Week by admin
Thanks to Social Media, Margelit Hoffman has gained 1,000 new friends and a profitable business. Now she asks some soul-searching questions about the impact of Facebook on her life as a Jewish women. Are you ready for her answers?

I joined Facebook right around the time my oldest son was born. I had been getting invitations for a while, and had been successfully ignoring them. But one of my closest friends, who lived long-distance, convinced me to join because it was “the easiest way to connect” and “all our old high school friends are on it.”
Since then I’ve used it to
- keep me occupied while I was nursing
- kill time during pregnancies when I couldn’t sleep at night
- stay connected to now almost 1,000 new and old friends
- learn the news that’s relevant to me
- ask a random smattering of friends where to find kosher restaurants in a given city, or how to potty train a two-year-old
- share random musings without having to direct them at anyone in particular
- build a profitable business for myself, and market my husband’s video production company
My excuse for using it now is that I work on Facebook, since I manage social media campaigns and teach social media marketing.
But my husband and I will be disabling our internet connection at home in the next few days, and all because we can’t get enough of the screen. We’ve found the internet to be a compelling way to turn away from each other, and to get our kids addicted to shows on Netflix (“Mommy, Bob the Builder doesn’t wear a kippah so I don’t have to either,” said my oldest, a four-year-old).
This will have big ramifications for us business-wise, since we work online, and I work from home. But I’ll just have to hang out at Starbucks while the kids are at gan to get my work done instead, and I won’t stay up all night googling while my husband is away on filming trips – I’ll either be reading books of Torah, painting, or sleeping.
The Woman on the Street
Rabbi Harizy, my husband’s shalom bayis teacher, teaches from the sefer Ohel Rachel. He gives over the concept of “the woman on the street,” which is a woman who has to go out and sell herself or sell anything or just be out there in order to make a living. Using this example helps drive the point home to men that they are to provide financially for their wives, and that this is an obligation of the Torah, and one he signs into via the ketubah.
We are reminded of the story of Yaakov Avinu’s daughter Dina, aka Shulamit, who was called Shulamit because she said hello to everyone. And that was what did her in.
Facebook can be used in a very private way, and the privacy settings are quite customizable. We can choose to friend or not befriend, who sees what, and what we post. When we use Facebook as a way to connect with dear friends worldwide, friends whom we otherwise may not get to communicate with, and for the greater good – think of all the reports the Third Intifadah page garnered, leading to Facebook shutting it down and Naqba Day turning out uneventful – we are using it to bring light and achdus into this world.
In defense of women throughout the frum world who work for a living, it is a chessed to our husbands that we put ourselves out there, as long as it is appropriate, and as long as it is actually lucrative. With social media marketing, this takes time to come to fruit, but Hashem rewards us for our intentions.
A Silent Churban
Part of keeping the Torah is building a fence around it. Facebook can be a tool for good. I love Social Media as much as anyone else, maybe more than most people, since it’s given me and my husband the opportunity to earn our Parnasa doing work that we love. But make no mistake – it is a distraction. Shmuel recently worked for Big Productions on a film for a Jewish organization called DaytoDisconnect, and he was shocked at how much people are controlled by their tech. Computers and smartphones are addictions that are silently destroying home life everywhere, and this is why an organization like DaytoDisconnect had to come about in the first place. And it’s the reason Shmuel and I are on the verge of banning the internet from our home, even though it may have great ramifications for our business.
On the other hand, if you follow the 4-Hour Workweek, which we are slowly attempting to do, this is a step in the right direction.
Where does someone like me, who uses Facebook and other social sites to promote my husband’s business and the work of Jewish nonprofits, draw the line? When does what I do remain chessed, and when does what I do go too far out the door, past the yard, onto the sidewalk, and dangerously close to the street?
When I’m feeling the rush of cars whizzing past, I go to naaleh.com and reconnect with the Torah. Rebbetzin Heller reminds me to get off the computer and clean the house before my husband comes home. After all, this is about chessed and building a bait neeman b’Yisrael. There is a time and a place for each kind of chessed.
(image by djtransformer)
——————-
With her husband, Shmuel, Margelit Hoffman is the founder of Hoffman Productions, a video production and online marketing company where she focuses primarily on social media marketing. Besides managing the social media campaigns of businesses and nonprofits in a variety of fields, Margelit teaches social media and online marketing classes. Margelit is mom to three adorable children.
——————
PS: This article has sparked a lively debate of Margelit’s move to ban the internet on various Jewish mommy blogs. Check out these great posts:
- Ima2Seven
- JewishMOM
- Life in the Married Lane




Kol HaKavod Margalit for taking this step. I’ve also been struggling with this lately. Being on Facebook and on the internet in general makes me angry, cynical, moody and I think it’s because as the article touched upon, instead of learning Torah or spending more time with my family I’m wasting my time on the net. Lately I’ve spent less time on Facebook and instead I’ve been doing exercise, and learning, and reading religious books and spending valuable time with my family and I couldn’t be happier.
Margelit,
I absolutely identify with everything you’ve written. At the same time, I think we let it swallow us, because we have other unresolved issues. Once we address these, it is easier to set boundaries. If we find ways to make connecting with our families and values more attractive, we won’t be spending so much time on the net.
If you are in Israel, Rimon ISP has a program which allows you to schedule the Internet connection and disconnect at predetermined times. it is called TizmunNeto. While I have the admin rights and can change the settings, it has really helped me become more disciplined about my internet use.
Try it out before unplugging.
Hi Leah,

I think I heard of that – great idea. I also use e.ggtimer that sets off an annoying tone when my pre-set time is up (you can use this for anything).
I’ve already unplugged and am happy with the results so far. I sleep better, am less snappy with my kids, and I get more exercising and cleaning done. I’m also less distracted when hanging out with my husband. All around, it’s for the best.
Margelit
Margelit,
Trying to set boundaries on the internet is like trying not to eat that piece of chocolate cake that is on the table. It’s better not to have it around. Just unplug. At the same time it may also be an option for me. Already you have one person trying to get you not to unplug. The internet is mostly waste and you know it. Even with the valid reason of needing it for parnassah how much time is actually wasted on it? You’ll feel much better disconnecting, especially your neshama if you learn Torah, paint or sleep. The yetzer hara tries to persuade in sneaky ways that you’re doing the wrong thing but you know you are doing the right thing and i applaud you and your husband for taking this step.
Thank you Akiva! So far so good…
I wasn’t trying to convince Margalit of anything, and she surely knows what will work best for her. From the post, it looked like she still planned to work on the net from hotspots, so I wanted to present another alternative, namely scheduled net access from home, with on and off hours.
Besides unplugging, it is also helpful to explore why the net is so attractive to us and what needs it fills, because those needs aren’t going to go away, so long as the issues are not addressed.
Indeed – it fulfills a need in me for connection and productivity. But I also have the kind of personality that’s over-producing and too connected. Like I need to relax more and not expect so much from one day.
-Margelit
Definitely. I used to take advantage of my commute time to say tehillim. Since I got an iphone, i justify checking my email and staying in touch with my kids via (private) facebook. But I look at my tehillim, and feel sad. Thank you for this reminder. I do think that it is personality types that got caught in this. I am the person who stayed up all night reading the book, and who can’t eat one piece of the chocolate cake. (I also can’t love my kids enough!) Disconnecting to connect is important, while at the same time I do use my connect to BE connected to my kids. My cousins follow our facebook conversations and ROTFL. so, balance…as in all things.
Yes, I also have that “all-the-way” type of personality. I find that strict boundaries work best for me; otherwise I’m constantly pushing them.

I also used to spend half an hour saying tehillim every night! Maybe I’ll pick it up again now…
Margelit
Thank you for sharing such a personal, challenging aspect of your life that many can relate to. Your approach is truly admirable.
Although slightly off topic, I wanted to share this recent L.A. Times article I ran into as I believe it touches on a very important issue in terms of the negative intellectual and psychological affects which social media is having on the younger generation.
Too Much Facebook Time May Be Unhealthy for Kids
http://www.latimes.com/health/boostershots/la-heb-facebook-teens-20110806,0,7575848.story
Hi Rivka,
Thanks for sharing this article! I’m going to write about it in an article for http://www.DaytoDisconnect.com – will keep you posted on when it goes up.
Thanks again!
Margelit
I really appreciate this article. While home, I have to use the computer, but it is SO hard to keep focused on more important things when the computer (and I don’t even use Facebook!) calls to me, “Hey, why don’t you Google this?” or “You never finished XYZ for work…” My kids need me, not the back of my head as I’m turned away to the computer screen. I have to be on the internet for my work and even family business (like school and dr’s ap’pts), but it’s hard to stay present for my kids. Sometimes, I flee the house! I have to say no even to a Blackberry or an iPhone because I know if I had easy internet access when away from home, it could ruin my life. I try not to use even my plain-Jane cell while going out with my kids because I feel like they need a break, too.
I completely agree, Rebecca. So far it’s been a struggle without the internet getting all the extra, non-work stuff done at work, and planning everything I need in advance so that it happens. It requires a ton of organization. I’m not the most organized person, but so far the benefits outweigh anything negative. IY”H it should continue so.

Margelit
I would like your permission to reference this piece and talk about it on my blog, ideally to reprint it there; it has caused me to pause and think a lot about my own use of the computer and social media, and how it relates to my yiddishkeit and the raising of my kids. I am not prepared to remove the internet from the house, but that doesn’t mean there isn’t anything to assess here. Please let me know.
Hi ima2seven,
We’d be happy for you to discuss this article on your blog and link back to it. You can quote from it without reprinting the whole thing.
Thanks for asking!
PS. I love your blog!
Thank you for the kind compliment! My thoughts on your thoughts are up at Ima2seven.
Kol Hakavod!!
It’s so impressive that you and your husband are taking that step. I hope you have a way to get chizuk bc this isn’t easy at all!! But keep in mind, the hardest things are the most rewarding.
Thank you SM!

So far the benefits far outweigh any difficulties. I sleep more, eat less, snap at my kids less, and spend more quality time with my husband. Awesome.
Margelit
I get the impression I’m not the target audience of this site, but I found this post on Facebook (oh, the irony) and can’t help but give non-charedi view on some issues – see it as a little diversity
1. The evil internet: we are the always-on civilization. We definitely have addictive tendencies. Yet everything I’ve learned for business, and continue to learn, I learned online (not in kindergarten). I learn other things as well, and I love it. Google is my doorway to knowledge. We have one day of rest: Shabbat, which is our pure off-time, and I thank God for that.
2. The story of Dina: maybe there’s an interpretation like the one you described, but she was nabbed because the people of Shechem were evil. So evil they deserved to be killed by Dina’s brothers. I’m not a fan of blaming female victims for becoming victims (I’m sure you’re shocked). And if we blame Dina for this, do we blame Sara Imenu for getting nabbed by Pharaoh? Maybe she was a little too friendly and immodest. Maybe she spoke too much lashon harah (one of my favorite explanations for all evil). Yeah right.
3. Women should clean the house for their husbands: give me a humongous break. Anyone who works outside of the home knows that going to work is a picnic compared to taking care of kids. Husbands should be running home from their vacation/work to help their wives clean the house. I’m not saying that women should slack off, but when was the last time you met a slacker Jewish mom? Me neither. Our solid Jewish guilt guarantees we never slack off, yet always feel like we are. It’s husband heaven.
Hi Miriam,
Thanks for your feedback. A few things:
1. I am not chareidi, and if I were I wouldn’t be able to represent the chareidi POV (since there are so many:-)
2. Check out this campaign: http://www.DaytoDisconnect.com. Shabbat disconnection is cold turkey, but what they’re promoting is a healthy balance in everyday life. The most holy davening of the week is weekday mincha, davka because it’s in the middle of the day when you’re doing everything else.
3. 70 panim leTorah. No one blames Dina, but we know that modesty in general exists so as not to tempt the yetzer hara of others. I want to do my part in keeping the yetzer hara at bay, and not get myself into situations where I’m too visible (it might be too late for this anyway).
4. Can you point out where I wrote that women should clean the house for their husbands?
I want to do what’s best for my marriage, and to do something for my husband rather than a client at 10PM. My husband, as you know, is a German, and likes things clean. I want to do this for him not because of what someone else says I should be doing, but because a clean home helps him relax. Just as he has taken on paying the bills because he knows it stresses me out.
It’s called division of labor, and in my home we do it according to our specific needs, not according to who’s male and who’s female.
I also have those thoughts Miriam. They make perfect sense. I know all the reasons why Google is great… and I never heard this article say it’s not great. Problem is that I have to admit that our iphones (mine and husband’s) are wreaking havoc in our family life. I know it in my gut… And I think it’s important that someone goes online and even on facebook and says this OUT LOUD!
Alcohol has its time and place, food has its time and place, sex has its time and place, drugs have their time and place.

For everything there is a season. As you said, these things are not evil; otherwise I’d feel pretty bad about making my living online!
It’s a question of moderation. It’s time to admit that this is an addiction that some – not all – have. Someone who’s addicting to overeating can’t just quit eating, it requires moderation. That’s what I’m working toward with keeping the internet out of my home.
Rahel – you might like this: http://www.DaytoDisconnect.com.
Margelit
Miriam, of course the internet is good for many things and it does provide parnassah for a lot of people but there are many negative sides to it and I think that’s why Margelit has disconnected. You know how many hours are wasted on the internet iphone, etc?? Many hours. If the internet didn’t have it’s positive sides than it would be obvious that everybody would stay away.
As for your point #2 I have no idea what it has to do with the subject at hand. Seemed like an anti-something rant there, not sure.
As for point #3 that women should be cleaning the house for their husbands, I couldn’t find that on the thread. Maybe I missed it. I am charedi and I know in my circle a lot of emphasis is put on helping the wife around the home and trying to make her happy. This is what I’ve gotten from my learning and from my rabbis. I think it’s over stereotyping to say that women do housework while men go do their thing e.g. work, learn or whatever they do and to think that they don’t contribute to the work around the house. Chareidi men contribute plenty around the house and it’s not cause we’re being nice but it’s because it’s our obligation to do so.
I don’t think men going to work is considered a vacation to men. You expect us men to respect women yet how can you say you respect men when you consider their going to work a vacation. Men work very hard. Should they help around the house after work? of course, but don’t expect them to come home full of energy.
Thanks Akiva,

We’ve disconnected from the internet at home because I’m trying to create more peace in my home.
Like Hashem, oseh shalom bimromav – it’s between fire and water, male and female.
The main thing we should all be doing is helping each other out, and doing whatever needs to make the other comfortable. Whether that’s cleaning, cooking, making money, changing diapers, paying bills…. It really doesn’t matter who’s doing what as long as the couple agrees on who will do what, and as long as they help each other in their respective areas whenever is necessary.
It’s called teamwork.
Margelit
I’m really impressed with this discussion thread. My Rov told me not to use facebook even though I could increase traffic to my blog, ten, one hundred, one thousand, ten thousand? fold and I’m holding steady at 673 hits, last I checked. I’m a bit creeped out by facebook’s acessibility, people from your past suddenly “friending” you etc and so I stay away.